Live nowOn the air 24/7Watch live
Play

TechMYTH OR FACT?

Composer Huang Ruo calls opera 'the last dance of humanity'

Huang Ruo, the New York-based conductor behind M. Butterfly and The Monkey King, says AI pop singers sound beautiful but are not real; it's an opinion, not a study.

Photo: CTV Santa Cruz County · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN
▶ As it aired · Tech

Watch it as it aired: Hank Ledger and Vera Bullock on this story, from Weekend Edition at 7:04 AM ET. Cartoon anchors, real headline: the facts are South China Morning Post's, the jokes are ours.

Photo: Huang Ruo
Photo: CTV Santa Cruz County · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN

At a glance

The real story

The reporting behind this segment. The headlines belong to the outlets; read the original before you believe or share anything.

What BBN said about it

  1. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorA composer says opera is the last dance of humanity, and he said it in Hong Kong while talking about AI pop singers.

  2. Vera Bullock · Co-AnchorThe claim under review: AI can never sing like a person, and I know because my shower has never once been wrong about me.

  3. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorThat's your proof. The shower.

  4. Vera Bullock · Co-AnchorIt has acoustics, Hank. Hank, rule on it.

  5. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorNina isn't on the desk this time, so I'll read the report.

  6. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorIt's the South China Morning Post: Huang Ruo, who is fifty and based in New York, spoke at a Hong Kong talk on music and culture.

  7. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorHis quote is that AI pop singers sing so beautifully, but it's not real, and so he believes theatre and opera are the last dance of humanity.

  8. Vera Bullock · Co-AnchorBeautifully. One word, and I'm putting it on a mug. The rest of the sentence is a draft.

  9. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorThe limits: it's one composer's opinion in a talk. No study, no test, no ruling.

  10. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorI'd call it IT'S COMPLICATED. He's selling tickets, and the quote is the trailer.

  11. Vera Bullock · Co-AnchorThen my new belief is that I'll be in the audience in Hong Kong, and they're inviting people to take part, so I'll be singing.

  12. Hank Ledger · Lead AnchorBetween Two Lights has sixteen singers already. The part they've left for you is standing.

▶ Watch BBN liveMore Tech →

More Shorts

All videos →
  1. ▶ As it aired · TechBrain scans reveal a 'number line' for comparing valuesRead the story
  2. Photo: Craig Howell from San Carlos, CA, USA · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN
    ▶ As it aired · TechIndie developers build quirky apps for the iPhone DuoRead the story
  3. ▶ Interviews · U.S.Jay-Z Picks Super Bowl Headliner: A One-Name BallotAbout this segment
  4. Photo: Dllu · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN, shared under CC BY-SA 4.0
    ▶ As it aired · TechFeds want robotaxis to signal 'I'm driving' with cyan lightsRead the story
  5. Photo: MichaelBueker · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN, shared under CC BY-SA 3.0
    ▶ As it aired · TechCambridge scientists create a $10 chip that could put a medical lab…Read the story
  6. ▶ Interviews · U.S.Wildwood Review: Influencer's 'Unassisted' Book Has AssistantAbout this segment
  7. Photo: ESO/A. Ghizzi Panizza ( www.albertoghizzipanizza.com ) · CC BY 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN
    ▶ As it aired · TechA nanoparticle revealed the tiny impact of a single gas atomRead the story
  8. Photo: Paowee · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN, shared under CC BY-SA 4.0
    ▶ As it aired · TechInk droplets in motion snag top prize in Nikon Small World contestRead the story
  9. ▶ Interviews · U.S.Deep-Sea Siphonophores: Captain Admits Labels Were Gull PoopAbout this segment
  10. Photo: NASA · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons · altered by BBN
    ▶ As it aired · TechWebb's 'little red dots' are bigger than 'little' allowsRead the story
Aired onWeekend EditionThe week's stories, the weekend's weirdnessAbout the show →

The story so far

  1. Hong Kong rethinks sustainable dining after Michelin drops Green Star · South China Morning Post
  2. Fotografiska opens photo museum in Shenzhen, its fifth worldwide · South China Morning Post
  3. Fotografiska opens a photo museum in Shenzhen · South China Morning Post
  4. Qipology founder shares her Hong Kong lunch and dim sum picks · South China Morning Post
  5. Composer Huang Ruo calls opera 'the last dance of humanity' (this story)

From the archive: everything BBN aired on Saturday, October 24, 2026 · the Tech archive · all months